banner.gif (3468 bytes)


Columbo's cases if they went to trial.
Sent to us by Nathan Sikes, Birmingham, AL

Imagine Columbo's cases went to court did you ever wonder how they would turn out?

1. PRESCRIPTION: MURDER

California v. Ray Fleming

GUILTY -- Life

 

2. RANSOM FOR A DEAD MAN

California v. Leslie Williams

GUILTY -- Life

 

3. MURDER BY THE BOOK

California v. Kenneth Franklin

GUILTY -- Two life sentences; no parole

 

4. DEATH LENDS A HAND

California v. Robert Brimmer

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

5. DEAD WEIGHT

California v. Major General Martin Hollister

GUILTY -- Life

 

6. SUITABLE FOR FRAMING

California v. Dale Kingston

GUILTY -- Life plus twenty

 

7. LADY IN WAITING

California v. Beth Chadwick

GUILTY -- Twenty years

 

8. SHORT FUSE

California v. Roger Stanford

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

9. BLUEPRINT FOR MURDER

California v. Elliot Markham

GUILTY -- Death

 

10. ETUDE IN BLACK

California v. Alex Benedict

GUILTY -- Death

 

11. THE GREENHOUSE JUNGLE

California v. Jarvis Goodland

GUILTY -- Life

 

12. THE MOST CRUCIAL GAME

Paul Hanlon

DISMISSED -- Insufficient evidence

 

13. DAGGER OF THE MIND

Nicholas Framer Lillian Stanhope

DISMISSED -- Insufficient evidence

 

14. REQUIEM FOR A FALLING STAR

California v. Nora Chandler

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

15. A STITCH IN CRIME

Dr. Barry Mayfield

DISMISSED -- Insufficient evidence

 

16. THE MOST DANGEROUS MATCH

California v. Emmet Clayton

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

17. DOUBLE SHOCK

California v. Dexter Paris

GUILTY -- Twenty years

California v. Norman Paris

GUILTY -- Twenty years

 

18. LOVELY BUT LETHAL

California v. Viveca Scott

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

19. ANY OLD PORT IN A STORM

California v. Adrian Carsini

GUILTY -- Twenty years, chance of parole in five.

 

20. CANDIDATE FOR CRIME

California v. Nelson Hayward

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

21. DOUBLE EXPOSURE

California v. Bart Kepple

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

22. PUBLISH OR PERISH

California v. Riley Greenleaf

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

23. MIND OVER MAYHEM

California v. Marshall Cahill

GUILTY -- Twenty years, chance of parole in five

 

24. SWAN SONG

California v. Tommy Brown

NEVER TRIED -- PLEA BARGAIN -- Two Life sentences, chance of parole in twenty.

 

25. A FRIEND IN NEED

California v. Mark Halperin

GUILTY -- Life for 1st degree murder, Twenty-five years for aiding and abetting

California v. Hugh Caldwell

GUILTY -- Life for 1st degree murder, Twenty-five years for aiding and abetting

 

26. AN EXERCISE IN FATALITY

Milo Janus

DISMISSED -- Insufficient evidence

 

27. NEGATIVE REACTION

California v. Paul Galesko

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

28. BY DAWN’S EARLY LIGHT

California v. Lyle C. Rumford

NEVER TRIED -- PLEA BARGAIN -- Ten years, U.S. Court-Martial

 

29. TROUBLED WATERS

California v. Hayden Danziger

GUILTY -- Life

 

30. PLAYBACK

California v. Harold Van Wyck

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

 

31. A DEADLY STATE OF MIND

California v. Marcus Collier

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

32. FORGOTTEN LADY

Grace Wheeler Willis

UNSOLVED -- Mrs. Wheeler died a month after the case.

 

33. A CASE OF IMMUNITY

Secretary Hassan Salah

DISMISSED -- Due to "sweetheart" deal influenced by U.S./foreign relations

 

34. IDENTITY CRISIS

Nelson Brenner (a.k.a., "Steinmetz")

NEVER TRIED -- Brenner was sprung from LAPD custody and became a fugitive of justice.

 

35. A MATTER OF HONOR

Luis Montoya

GUILTY -- BY MEXICAN LAW -- Hung to death.

 

36. NOW YOU SEE HIM

California v. Stefan Mueller (a.k.a., "The Great Santini")

GUILTY -- Death

 

37. LAST SALUTE TO THE COMMODORE

California v. Swanny Swanson

NOT GUILTY -- Insufficient evidence

 

38. FADE IN TO MURDER

California v. Ward Fowler

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

 

39. OLD FASHIONED MURDER

Ruth Lyton

DISMISSED -- Insufficient evidence

 

 

40. THE BYE-BYE SKY-HIGH I.Q. MURDER CASE

California v. Oliver Brandt

NEVER TRIED -- PLEA BARGAIN -- Twenty years, chance of parole in seven

 

 

41. TRY AND CATCH ME

California v. Abigail Mitchell

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

42. MURDER UNDER GLASS

California v. Paul Gerard

NEVER TRIED -- Mr. Gerard committed suicide before going to trial

 

43. MAKE ME A PERFECT MURDER

California v. Kay Freestone

NOT GUILTY -- Good Lawyer

 

44. HOW TO DIAL A MURDER

California v. Eric Mason

GUILTY -- Death

 

45. THE CONSPIRATORS

California v. Joseph Devlin

GUILTY -- Death

COLUMBO CASES IF THEY WENT TO TRIAL -- PART II: The ABC Years